I purchased a Sawyer Squeeze when they first came out and only used it twice. So over a 21 day ride and another week in the country, I would guess that we filtered 150-160 liters of water. After a few days in the Sierra Maestra the flow rate started to slow considerably. Backpacker notes that it doesnt change the taste of gross water and doesnt do well with silt, but Gear Junkie elaborates that you simply shake it to clean it. For folks filtering their own water, the Sawyer Squeeze is the most adaptable filter, able to go along on a day hike or a long-distance backpacking trip with equal ease. We prefer to attach the Squeeze to a SmartWater bottle or CNOC hydration bladder to eliminate these problems altogether. That price per liter ranges from $0.40 per liter all the way to less than $0.01 per liter, so you can find your own personal sweet spot. Most of these filters have a hard time surviving falls, and water expanding into ice at freezing temperatures can also break them. Mostly because there is no dirty bottle involved. REI clearanced a bunch of these out last fall at a super cheap price (1st generation? Also, maybe you noticed, maybe you didn't, but the MSR Guardian is the only hand pump filtration and water purification system that made the cut for us. Top 28 Product Ratings Displaying 1 - 5 of 28 < Previous | Compare | Next > Show full specification details Best Overall Filter for Personal Use Sawyer Squeeze $29 at Amazon $41 at REI 78 OVERALL SCORE Water Quality 9.0 Durability & Maintenance 6.0 Treatment Time 9.0 Weight & Packability 8.0 Ive just placed an order for BeFree and 2L bottle as I dont quite trust the 0.6L that comes with the filter. NEW! So ask yourself: how patient are you, really? This pocked-sized water filter is very compact and light, weighing just 5 ounces. The fact that I never read the instructions is partly to blame. When youre moving fast, the MSR TrailShot is our top pick. Enter theMSR TrailShot. It also made the best-of lists on four out of the seven sites we aggregated from. I was pretty impressed with the one liter set up. Complaints abound about the bags. I have to say that the water bags that come with the Sawyer Squeeze's are terrible. While you can use it for refilling water bottles for hiking, I think a BeFree 3L, BeFree 1L, Sawyer Squeeze and better solutions for hikers because you can filter more water with less effort and they include the ability to transport water if you dont need to use it right away. 99.9 or 99.99% is good enough? And, it does all this at a fraction of the size and cost of the Guardian. The strong flow rate of the Katadyn BeFree filter. In theory, the Micro combines the flow-rate of the Sawyer Squeeze with the weight savings of the Sawyer MINI. Beware cross-contamination! Take special care to keep your filters secure, and if you know youre camping at temps below freezing, consider sleeping with your water filter in your sleeping bag (double bagging it in a zip bag will keep you dry). there's no comparison with how much faster and easier it is to get water through the slightly bigger original Sawyer Squeeze vs the Mini. Better safe than sorry. Then remove the hose and let the water pour out. Its also worth noting that Ive heard equally good reports when using the Trailshot on pre-strained turbid desert water. Our experts test thousands of products each year using thoughtful test plans that bring out key performance differences between competing products. No duplication of photos, maps, or text without permission. I will say though that the trailshot definitely has a place, for shorter trips, trail running, or if you only have to filter water for yourself i think that its a good choice, but the sawyer squeeze is more universal for multiple applications. The special edition 10th issue of The Bikepacking Journal is one you wont want to miss! Photo courtesy Liz Thomas. You help support OutdoorGearLab's product testing and reviews by purchasing from our retail partners. Carying syringe is a pain, squeezing bags isnt fun. It seems to be the most effective of the 3 and perhaps this strength contributes to low flow rate and pressure required to filter water. But its a filter, not a miracle worker: consider pre-filtering your water, or at least gathering it into a bottle or bucket and letting it settle a bit before filtering off the top. Ive had it for over a year (along with my BeFree filter). Still, different water filters have different wait times the length of time you have to wait to turn that dirty water into clean water. Originally I chose the Trailshot because it made more sense to me. Its not exactly a filter per se, but we like the rechargeableKatadyn Steripen Ultra Water Purifierfor its quick and easy use. The MSR Trailshot Water Filter is a highly portable backcountry water filter that has a water fountain spout so you can drink on the go without having to carry a water bottle. You can use the TrailShot to fill your group's water bottles, but it takes a little more time and hand strength than other methods. Most folks carry some form of backup chemical purifier, such as iodine purification tablets or chlorine dioxide droplets. What youre doing and who youre doing it with will go a long way to helping you decide on the perfect water filter for you. Though you can filter from the dirty bags the Squeeze comes with into a clean filtered water bottle if you like, we prefer to drink straight through the sports top, getting our fix instantly. When you suck on the tube, dirty water travels through the tube, into the filter, and comes clean out the bite valve. Numerous waterborne viruses cause the stomach flu, which can knock you out of commission for days at a time so drop that extra cash and make sure youre covered. Sawyer Squeeze seems like a tested and trusted filter, although the flow rate and convenience factors are low. Use it in-line with a hydration bladder or simply drink right from the source. Photo by Mike Unger. The weight of Mini is significantly less compared to Sawyer Squeeze. I fail to see the appeal. Youll also want to think about that filters end-of-days. If you are drinking directly from the source the clean water is immediate and therefore much faster than filling a bottle! It really is quite good at doing what it was designed to do, which is filter protozoans and bacteria for one person on the go. How this system works: Cut the hydration hose tube in two. If you're into ultralight backpacking, chances are that you've owned a Sawyer Squeeze or a Mini. Purifiers remove protozoan cysts, bacteria, AND viruses. You can hang up the Sawyer Squeeze with the CNOC bag and use it as a gravity system. And, to assure complete independence, we buy all the products we test ourselves. $49.95 Used Value: $29.97 Sale Value: $44.96 Features & Specs 20 Reviews Tweet Share Submit From ultralight backpacking trips to epic mountain bike rides, the MSR TrailShot Microfilter provides ultra-compact purification, allowing you to drink directly from streams and lakes on the trail. Sawyer Mini vs MSR TrailShot Water Filter The Emporium Outdoors 29.8K subscribers Subscribe 10K views 5 years ago Sawyer Mini vs MSR TrailShot Water Filter After running with the Sawyer water. This certainly helped, but it never seemed to have the virulent flow that it did out of the box. I'd agree a Cnoc bag with a squeeze is awesome. Although she often travels solo, she values its ability to handle silty water and to maintain in the field easily. The one thing to keep in mind though, after you dip the soft bottle into the water, and then hold the filter upside down and start drinking, untreated water can potentially run down the outside and into your mouth if youre not paying attention to what youre doing. Nothings instantaneous when youre outside doing things for yourself and water filtration isnt any different. Its best used by highly mobile athletes who are in a big hurry and *maybe* carry very small water bottles in vests. Oh I forgot I can gravity fees 1L water in 1min with my squeeze for the same weight as the trailshot. A hardcore pump filter like the MSR Guardian Purifier with medical grade hollow fiber technology and virus protection might be the right choice for your next Andean alpine expedition; while a simple handheld squeeze filter like the MSR TrailShot is perfect for trail running and ultra light backpacking. They have claimed that this one won't let you die no matter how long the journey is. The TrailShot is rated to remove 99.99999% of bacteria and 99.9% or protozoa (giardia and cryptosporidium.) Get Backpacking Light news, updates, gear info, skills, and commentary delivered into your inbox 1-2x/week. The GravityWorks has a 0.2-micron filter, which means youre safe from the major microscopic concerns in the US and Canada. Photo by Liz Thomas. Simply flip your filter system so that clean water runs from the Clean Bag into the Dirty Bag. As it falls through the filter, things that can create clogs will dislodge from the filter into the dirty bag. You must log in or register to reply here. This makes it perfect for trail running and fast and light hiking when you want to carry as little gear as possible. You might need to drink with the hole up to minimize spill which should be minimal if not turning bottle upside down. I am not worried about the Hydropak made water bottle to fail. To find the best water filter for you, ask yourself a few questions: Are you headed out for a trail run, going backpacking for a month, or traveling abroad for a year? So it was no surprise that the MSR TrailShot is also ideal for weekend and overnight backcountry bikepacking trips. The difference between backpacking filters and purifiers is the level of protection. You can also use the TrailShot to fill water bottles, or reservoirs directly without removing them from your pack if your hose diameter fits into the TrailShots drink spout. If for some reason your filter becomes inoperable, its best not to have to sit around your stove and boil water for the 1-3 minutes the EPA says it takes to purify it every time you want a drink. Got a group to care for? Scoring well across the board, the TrailShot is a Jack-of-all-trades kind of filter. Whether it's living on the road or living out of a backpack, traveling and just being in the outdoors is second nature to me. 1-3 minutes the EPA says it takes to purify, thru-hiking, backpacking, hiking, running, camping-related, fitness, water sports-related, snow-related, bicycle-related, apparel, outdoor apparel, outdoor clothing, bike-related, detergent, laundry, care and maintenance, kate hoch, men's, women's, men's apparel, women's apparel, popular, bike touring, best touring bike, trek 520, surly long haul trucker, surly disc trucker, salsa bikes, fuji bikes, main, bicycle, mike unger, Best Baby and Toddler Carriers for Hiking of 2023. When you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission. So I spent twenty (20) minutes trying to stick a circular piece of polyethylene correctly in that gap to insulate it and have the water going. Cant be used in gravity mode from what I see. How can we improve GearLab? The MSR TrailShot also comes in a tidy package. First-Time Customer Discount. Given its size, weight, and price, the TrailShot seems like the perfect system for jaunts where there are plenty of water sources to dip into. While taller and skinnier than a Nalgene and relatively heavy at 10.9 ounces, this filter wins for subtlety, as it looks much like a coffee cup (in fact, it fits in most cup holders). Upon first use it was clear that this product is a winner for such exploits. A Membership is required to post in the forums. I just bought the BeFree and in my kitchen, I am blown away with how fast the rate of flow is with CLEAN water. However, it removes 99.99999% of all bacteria and 99.9999% of all protozoa. 2023 Gear Guide to Lightweight Hiking @ REI. Frog eggs, suspended solids and stuff. The Sawyer Squeeze systems us a 28mm threaded top, so they can also be screwed onto a standard disposable bottle. Its also the most expensive when it comes to price per liter filtered; as each replaceable filter only goes for 150 liters, the cost per liter shakes out to $0.40 per liter. Then, just scoop the water into your dirty container for filtering.
Stump Grinding Slogans,
Calibration Testing Laboratory,
Carlyle 850 Jump Starter Charger,
Drive Safe Someone Loves You Font,
Articles S